Sandwiches and More

Walnut Tofu Bagel Burger

A vegan delight!  A surprisingly tasty patty with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and mustard on an Everything bagel and a side salad with vinaigrette.

The Cuban Bagel Sandwich

Jennie-O smoked turkey and ham on a plain bagel with provolone cheese, baby spinach, mayo, and pickles.

Chipotle Turkey Bagel Sandwich

Jennie-O smoked turkey and provolone on a plain bagel with spinach leaves, chipotle mayo and thinly sliced red onion.

Tuna Melt Panini

Approaching tuna-melt perfection, Our sandwiches have the ideal tuna-to-cheese ratio!

Grilled Cheese Panini

A classic turned up to 11! Rich cheddar cheese and Mozarella!

Grab-and-Go Sandwiches

See our cooler for tuna salad or chicken salad sandwiches.  Pick it up with your morning coffee and it’s ready for a quick lunch later!

Classic PB&J

You know, for kids!  Ask for a made-to-order peanut butter and jelly sandwich.


Soup & Salads

Caesar Salad

A mix of fresh, locally-grown greens, roasted chicken, croutons and caesar dressing

Garden Salad

A mix of locally-grown romaine lettuce, iceberg lettuce and red cabbage with sliced cucumber, and grape tomatoes.  Add chicken for $1.00 more.

Soup du jour

Our soups are always homemade, never from a mix or can.  Served from 11:00 am until gone – and they go quick!

Cup $3.00
Bowl $4.00


Caramel Rolls

Gooey and so delicious!  We bake them fresh every morning.


Large, tasty and homemade – and perfect with a cup of coffee.  Our variety of scones changes daily, but you’ll typically find blueberry, pecan, cranberry or chocolate chip.

Giant Muffins

Blueberry, chocolate chip, cranberry and cinnamon streusel are favorites here at The Goodness.

Other Bakery Items

Stop in or call ahead and find out what else we have homemade and fresh baked in our bakery case.  Quite often you’ll find bread pudding, lemon cakes, and more!


Our giant, fresh-baked cookies are a real treat, any time of the day!  Choose from chocolate chunk or white chocolate cranberry.

One Cookie $1.00
Three Cookies $2.00


Jalapeño Business

It’s a cowboy-sized Amigo bagel, egg, cream cheese, and cheddar.

Homemade Quiche

Fresh made from scratch with local farm-fresh eggs!

Bagel & Lox

Toasted bagel split with cream cheese, cured and cold-smoked salmon, red onion, and capers on each side.

Croque Ma’ham

A plain bagel with Swiss cheese, Fertile Acreage ham, Dijon mustard, and egg.

Everything Everything Sandwich

Fresh giant Everything Black Hills Bagels with bacon, egg, Swiss cheese, chive and onion cream cheese, red onion, and spinach.

Oatmeal or Muesli

Gluten-free, GMO-free, and made with real food ingredients! Available in a variety of flavors.